MX23RW : Thursday, May 9 10:08:09| >> :60:1052:1052:

Jim Goodwin calls for VAR for penalty-box calls in Scottish Premiership

The St Mirren boss does not think Scottish clubs could fund a full VAR system.

St Mirren manager Jim Goodwin has called for Scottish football to consider a stripped-down version of VAR and put an end to "soft" spot-kicks in the Premiership.

There have been 63 penalties awarded in the top flight this term – but Goodwin believes at least half were questionable.

Ironically, Goodwin – who recently pointed the finger at the culprits he claims are Scotland's main diving offenders – made his latest comments after seeing Rangers striker Alfredo Morelos booked for going down in the box against Livingston.

TV replays clearly showed the Colombian had been tripped by Livingston keeper Max Stryjek and Goodwin believes the whole drama, which included Gers boss Steven Gerrard being sent off for a four-letter outburst at referee John Beaton, could have been avoided if the officials had access to pitch-side monitors.

The Irishman understands Scottish clubs will struggle to afford the full VAR system used in England – but he sees no reason why a slimmed-down version focusing only on penalty-box fouls cannot be implemented north of the border.

"I think there has been just over 60 penalties awarded this season in the league and I would say about half of them fall into the soft category," said the Saints boss. "At least half.

"I think we need to help the referees as best we can because it's a really difficult job. And it's getting harder every year because the pace of the game is getting quicker all the time.

"I know they have VAR in the Premier League and people say it costs too much money for us to even consider.

"But I can assure you that the Rangers video analyst will have sent a clip of the penalty incident last night to the Rangers bench within half a minute. Those guys will have seen straight away that it was a penalty.

"Maybe I'm talking nonsense and we need FIFA to allow us to use our own system here in Scotland – but I don't see why we can't.

"We could have a TV monitor at the side of the pitch next to the dugout and for penalty-box incidents, it would be very easy to stop the game, have the referee run over and give the correct decision.

"Finances will always dictate and we don't have the resources that the Premier League, LaLiga and the Bundesliga have.

"But I'm not talking about the full bells-and-whistles VAR with the yellow and blue lines for offside. I'm just talking about penalty incidents because there are far too many being awarded this year that just quite frankly aren't penalties.

"These are key decisions which could mean the difference between making top six or bottom six or getting relegated and staying up."

Gerrard's champions-elect will be hoping to move within a point of the title when Goodwin's men head to Ibrox on Saturday – but the Paisley men are also just one win shy of confirming their place in the top six.

And the Saints boss said: "We're the only team in Europe who has been able to beat Rangers this season. We're very proud of that Betfred Cup result and it would make it even more special if we can go to Ibrox and get a win in the league.

"They've won every league game they've played at Ibrox this season so no-one has to tell us how difficult it will be.

"But we won't be going there to sit on our own 18-yard line. We're within touching distance of the top six now so we're going there to have a go."

ID:437782: cacheID:437782:1false2false3false:QQ:: from db desktop :LenBod:restore:4764:
Restore Data
Share this article now:
John Hughes in charge of Hibernian in 2010
Read Next:
John Hughes "bitterly disappointed" at penalty call in St Mirren defeat
>
rhs 2.0
Today's games header
Tables header RHS
TeamPWDLFAGDPTS
Championship Group
1Celtic220085275884
2RangersRangers220078255381
3Hearts20114637963
4Kilmarnock20114438652
5St Mirren21014246-446
6Dundee20024659-1341
Relegation Group
1Hibernian21014854-642
2Aberdeen22003749-1241
3Motherwell21015053-340
4Ross County21013459-2533
5St Johnstone20022550-2531
RLivingston21012563-3821
 
First Phase
1Celtic33246380265478
2RangersRangers33243672234975
3Hearts33195946341262
4Kilmarnock33131284334951
5St Mirren33127143843-543
6Dundee331011124454-1041
7Hibernian33912124451-739
8Motherwell33813124651-537
9Aberdeen33811143549-1435
10St Johnstone33710162446-2231
11Ross County3379173256-2430
RLivingston3339212259-3718


Sports Mole provides in-depth previews and predictions for every match from the biggest leagues and competitions in world football.
Argentina's Lionel Messi kisses the World Cup trophy after collecting the Golden Ball award on December 18, 2022Sign up for our FREE daily preview newsletter direct to your inbox!